What is the oldest continuous Protestant organization in New York City?

The oldest continuous Protestant organization in New York City is Trinity Church, which was founded in 1697. It holds a significant historical and cultural standing in the city, being an iconic example of Anglican architecture and a key player in the social and religious life of New Yorkers for over three centuries.

Marble Collegiate Church, while notable for its prominent location and influential leadership, was established in 1628, but it did not emerge as a continuous congregation in New York as early as Trinity Church. St. Patrick's Cathedral is a Roman Catholic institution founded in the 19th century and thus does not fit within the Protestant framework. First Presbyterian Church also has historical significance but does not predate Trinity Church in terms of establishment and continuity.

Consequently, Trinity Church stands out as the correct answer, representing not only the longest-standing Protestant organization in New York City but also a testament to the evolution of faith and community throughout the city's extensive history.